Imagine gathering friends or colleagues to invest together, but every time an opportunity comes up, half the group is excited, the other half is skeptical, and meetings drag on without clear decisions.

Soon, you’re chasing “shiny” deals that sound good in the moment but don’t fit together and trust starts to erode.

That’s what happens when your collective doesn’t have an investment thesis, a shared compass that points everyone in the same direction.

Your thesis is more than a nice statement for your website. It’s:

• The GPS that keeps your collective from wandering off course.

• The filter that helps you say “yes” to the right deals and “no” to distractions.

• The story you use to attract and keep aligned members, partners and investors.

Without it, even well-intentioned collectives risk losing focus, diluting returns and creating internal conflict.

What Is an Investment Thesis?

An investment thesis is a clear, concise framework that outlines:

• What you invest in,

• Why you invest in it,

• How you expect it to generate value or returns.

It also serves as a decision-making tool so opportunities can be evaluated quickly and consistently and as a storytelling tool so members, potential investors and partners instantly understand your focus.

A strong thesis reflects shared values, clear goals and a focused strategy that everyone in the group can stand behind.

Why Your Thesis Matters

Think of your thesis as your strategic compass. It helps you:

• Stay focused so you’re not chasing every “interesting” opportunity and to channel resources into investments that match your defined criteria.

• Build credibility that shows potential members, partners and investors that your collective operates with purpose and discipline.

• Align decision-making and reduces internal debates and misalignment when opportunities arise.

• Communicate clearly thereby, making it easy to pitch your collective clearly.

Common Pitfalls to Avoid

When creating your thesis, watch out for these traps:

1. Being too broad: “We invest in Africa” is vague; specificity builds credibility.

2. Changing focus too often. Consistency builds trust; avoid chasing every hot trend.

3. No metrics. Without measurable goals, you can’t track progress or prove results.

How to Develop Your Investment Thesis

When crafting your thesis, keep it clear, specific and inspiring. Use these four building blocks:

1. Your “Why”

   • What’s the core purpose driving your collective?

   • Is it steady financial returns, solving a social problem or unlocking overlooked opportunities?

     
     

2. Asset Class & Sector

• What kind of opportunities will you focus on?

• Examples: real estate, tech startups, agriculture, creative industries, renewable energy.

• The sharper you define it, the more targeted your sourcing will be.

3. Geography

• Specify the counties, cities or regions you will focus on.

• Why there? Consider growth potential, risk and familiarity.

4. Investment Stage & Criteria

• Are you targeting early-stage startups, growth-stage companies, developed properties or pre-development land?

• Define your deal filters: expected returns, risk tolerance, scalability, community involvement, etc.

Examples for you:

• ABC Investment Collective: “ABC collective invests in residential and land properties in rural areas of Ghana, focusing on locations with high potential for appreciation and community development. We aim to deliver 8–12% annual returns while improving housing availability and boosting local economies.”

• XYZ Investment Collective: “We invest in early-stage fintech and healthtech startups in East Africa that address financial inclusion and healthcare access. Our goal is to generate competitive returns while enabling access to essential services for underserved populations.”

Test your statement

• Does everyone understand it without explanation?

• Does it excite current and potential members?

• Does it make it easier to reject irrelevant opportunities?

Keeping Your Thesis Relevant

Your thesis should be stable but adaptable. Review it:

• Annually, during your end-of-year review.

• When conditions change like new policies, major economic shifts or significant member turnover.

Here’s a 3-Step Review Checklist:

1. Compare your last 12 months of deals to your thesis, did you stay on track?

2. Ask team/members: “Does our thesis still reflect our priorities?”

Putting Your Thesis to Work

Once defined, your thesis should guide:

• The opportunities you source and consider.

• The way you pitch your collective to the public.

• Your member onboarding materials.

• The metrics you track to measure success.

A strong investment thesis doesn’t just make you more effective. It makes your collective more trustworthy, attractive and sustainable.

We hope you found this resource useful!

Ready to launch your collective on Borderless? Visit www.onborderless.com and join our WhatsApp Channel for more resources and updates.

Need direct support? Send us a quick message on WhatsApp at +44 7503833773 or email hello@onborderless.com.